BY THE WAY: Tahri was never a hygiene problem

The Waqf Board should manage the litter at Kashmir’s shrines, not the tradition.

Dr Noour Ali Zehgeer

Tahri (Yellow Rice) was never merely food. It was and continues to be a spiritual lesson hidden inside an ordinary act. When a wealthy man, a poor man, an official or an ordinary visitor opened his hand to receive it, all of them stood for a moment in the same posture, as receivers before Rabb (Allah). The hand that normally commanded became the hand that waited. Wealth, position and authority temporarily lost their importance. The lesson was quiet but profound: however much we possess, we still live by what Rabb (Allah) allows to reach us.

Even the act of stopping carried meaning. Life pushes us constantly toward work, money, ambition and possession. The sacred interrupts that movement. For a moment you stop, you wait, you receive. You remember that rizq is not only what you earn. Rizq is also what reaches you.

Then another lesson begins. Sometimes you deliberately share your portion with another person. Sometimes an animal comes near and you allow it to eat. Sometimes a bird approaches and your hand opens again. In each of these moments the nafs is quietly examined. Will you hold tightly to what you have received, or will you allow another creation of Rabb to share in it. The first opening of the hand receives rizq. The second opening disciplines the nafs.

Sometimes something even more subtle happens. A little Tahri slips from your hand without you noticing. A few grains fall to the ground and you walk on, completely unaware. Moments later a bird arrives and eats them. To the ordinary eye something simply fell. To the mystical eye something may have reached where it was meant to go. The person does not know which bird received it. The bird does not know whose hand dropped it. Yet between the two, provision has completed another journey.

The bird itself carries a lesson. It owns nothing, holds no salary, controls nothing about tomorrow, and still it rises every morning and searches. A human being can possess houses, savings and security and still fear scarcity. Perhaps the bird is not merely eating your food. Perhaps it has come to teach your hand how to open.

This is why tahri cannot be understood as food distribution, and cannot be regulated as if it were. The act trained the hand, the appetite, the attention and the heart. Giving away what you do not want is easy. Sharing what you yourself desire, while the aroma is still strong and the fried onions still crisp, is something else entirely. Perhaps another person consumed your portion. Perhaps what was really consumed was a little of your greed.

None of this is theory. Stand near any shrine gate on a Thursday afternoon and the argument settles itself.

There is the labourer who has been carrying cement since morning, hands white with dust, who has not eaten since the tea at dawn. He does not come as a pilgrim and he does not pretend to. “I have thirty rupees in my pocket and a family waiting for it,” he says. “Here nobody asks me who I am or what I earn. I put out my hand like everybody else and the plate comes to me the same as it goes to the man in the car. Tell me where else in Kashmir that happens.”

There is the woman who does not eat her portion at all. She folds it carefully, holds it close on the bus, and carries it home across the town. Her son has been unwell for months. “It is not just rice for me,” she says. “It is tabarruk. I feed it to him with my own hand and I say Bismillah and I ask Rabb to accept it. The doctors have their medicine and I have this. You can tell me it is only food. I will still carry it home.”

There is the man who cooks it and gives it away, year after year, from his own pocket. He gave it when his daughter was ill and she recovered. He gave it when his brother went missing and he had nothing else to do with his hands. “This is my sadqa,” he says. “I do not distribute it for the Waqf Board and I do not distribute it for anybody’s permission. Whatever I have, some of it must leave my house. If you close this, you have not closed a kitchen. You have closed a door I have been walking through for twenty years.”

And there is the child in a grey school sweater who stops at the shrine on the way home because the shrine falls on the way home. For him it is neither tabarruk nor sadqa. It is the second meal of the day, eaten standing up, and on some days it is the better of the two. He does not have a statement to give. He has an open hand and a full mouth and he is back in the lane before anybody notices him.

These are the people who are actually standing in the courtyard. Not one of them is a sanitation problem.

So I respectfully ask Dr. Darakhshan Andrabi to consider something larger. If cleanliness is genuinely the concern, then make cleanliness the mission. Use institutional influence to improve waste management around neighbourhoods, settlements and public spaces across Kashmir. Within Waqf managed shrines, build exemplary systems for sanitation, waste segregation, composting, food waste recovery and humane management of birds and animals. Let the shrines become models of environmental responsibility.

But do not confuse a management failure with a spiritual failure. If Tehri creates litter, manage the litter. If crowds create disorder, manage the crowds. If disposable materials create waste, redesign the method of distribution. Modernise the management, improve the sanitation, strengthen the system. Do not erase the meaning.

There is a further point the Chairperson should weigh, and weigh carefully. For years now a particular argument has been made about Kashmir’s shrines from outside the tradition: that their value lies in what they prevent. Shrines have been described as a firewall, a soft counterweight, an instrument of de-radicalisation. The framing was never about faith. It reduced centuries of devotion to a security utility, useful for as long as it served a purpose and disposable after that. Those who spoke this way were never interested in what happens inside the heart of a person standing in a shrine courtyard with an open hand.

When the custodian of these shrines begins to strip away the living practice and keep only the clean floor and the maintained wall, she is not defeating that argument. She is completing it. She is converting a place of surrender into an administered facility, and she is doing it with her own hands, which is precisely what the outside framing always wanted and could never accomplish on its own. This is not modernisation. It is the quiet acceptance of somebody else’s definition of what a shrine is for.

It should also be said plainly that this is not a recent habit that grew out of carelessness. Tahri has been cooked, carried and distributed at these shrines for decades upon decades, through seasons of plenty and seasons of fear, passed from mothers to daughters and from one neighbourhood chowk to the next. A practice that old is not a logistical inconvenience that appeared last year. It is the institution itself, in its working form.

Every sacred place has two forms of architecture. One is made of stone, timber, domes and gates. The other is made of memory, gesture, compassion and meaning. The first is easy to renovate. The second can disappear quietly, and once it does, no amount of marble, paint or administration will bring it back.

The rice was eaten, but the fragrance remained. The hands grew older, but the memory remained. If modernisation preserves the building and removes the behaviour that taught humility, generosity, tawakkul and remembrance, then what exactly have we preserved.
(STRAIGHT TALK COMMUNICATIONS EXCLUSIVE)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *