Born With Blueprint: Can DNA Influence What Upbringing Cannot Change?

An intriguing story of inherited instincts, human behaviour and the eternal debate between nature and nurture.

Anil Kumar Sharma
Some stories remain tucked away in the corners of our memory for years. We may forget the magazine in which we read them, the date of publication or even the finer details, but the central idea continues to intrigue us.

I recall reading an unusual story in Reader’s Digest nearly twenty years ago. It was about an adopted child whose adult behaviour raised a rather uncomfortable question: Can a person inherit certain behavioural tendencies from biological parents whom he has never known, despite being brought up in an entirely different family?

At first, it sounded like one of those stories that publishers bring out to surprise their readers. But the more I thought about it, the more interesting the subject became. After all, we have spent generations believing that children are largely a reflection of their parents, their home environment, education and family values. What happens when biology appears to tell a different story?

Let me take you through an extraordinary American case that brings this debate alive.

The story concerns Jeffrey Landrigan, born Billy Hill in 1962. His teenage biological mother abandoned him when he was barely six months old. He was subsequently adopted by Nick and Dot Landrigan and grew up with an adoptive sister.

One would normally expect that a child taken into a new family would gradually absorb its habits, discipline and values. But Jeffrey’s childhood was troubled. He reportedly displayed violent temper tantrums from a very early age, developed alcohol and substance abuse problems while still young, and repeatedly came into conflict with the law.

By the age of twenty, he had already committed murder and was serving a prison sentence.

The more disturbing chapter of his story began when another inmate noticed his striking resemblance to a prisoner on death row in Arkansas. His name was Darrel Hill. An investigation into Jeffrey’s biological identity revealed that Darrel was his biological father.

What followed was almost unbelievable.

His biological father had been convicted of a brutal murder. His grandfather had a violent criminal history and had been killed by police during a bank robbery. Earlier generations of his biological family also reportedly had records of serious violence.

Here was a young man who had grown up without knowing these relatives, yet his own life appeared to be following a disturbing pattern of violence in his biological family.

Was it merely coincidence? Or was there something in his genetic inheritance that deserved closer examination?

The story did not end there.

In 1989, after escaping from prison, Jeffrey reached Phoenix, Arizona, where he murdered Chester Dean Dyer during a burglary. He was convicted of felony murder and sentenced to death.

During his subsequent legal appeals, his defence team sought to present a rather unusual argument. They wanted the court to consider his biological family history, his mother’s alleged consumption of alcohol and drugs during pregnancy, his early childhood difficulties and the possibility that his genetic inheritance had contributed to his behavioural problems.

A neuropsychological assessment suggested that several factors, acting together, might have affected his ability to control impulses and understand the consequences of his actions.

His biological inheritance was now being discussed in a courtroom, not merely in a family conversation.

The US Supreme Court eventually examined the matter in 2007 in Schriro v. Landrigan. The Court upheld his death sentence, principally because Jeffrey himself had refused to allow his lawyer to present mitigating evidence during the original sentencing proceedings. He had effectively told the court to proceed with the death penalty.

He was executed in Arizona in October 2010.

But the legal outcome did not settle the scientific question that makes this case so fascinating.

Can we inherit a temperament just as we inherit the colour of our eyes?

Let us look at the science behind the story.

DNA is often described as the biological blueprint of human life. It carries instructions that influence our physical characteristics, our biological functioning and our susceptibility to certain conditions.

But scientists have also discovered that genes can influence aspects of our temperament and personality. Some individuals may have a greater natural tendency towards impulsiveness, risk-taking, emotional sensitivity or difficulty regulating anger.

This does not mean that there is a particular gene for becoming a criminal. There is no such simple formula. Human behaviour is far too complicated to be explained by a single biological switch.

Genes may influence our tendencies, but the environment in which we grow up can strengthen, moderate or redirect them.

This brings us to the familiar debate between Nature and Nurture.

Nature is what we inherit. Nurture is what we acquire through our parents, family, education, surroundings and experiences.

Consider two children growing up under the same roof. They attend the same school, eat at the same dining table, receive similar parental attention and are exposed to the same family values. Yet one may grow up to be patient, disciplined and compassionate, while the other may be restless, impulsive and argumentative.

Parents often wonder where they went wrong. Sometimes, perhaps, they did not go wrong at all. Children are individuals, not manufactured products coming out of the same family factory!

Even siblings born to the same parents can have remarkably different personalities. Identical twins brought up in different surroundings have also provided researchers with fascinating insights into the influence of inherited characteristics.

The point is not that upbringing has little importance. On the contrary, a supportive family, good education, discipline and emotional security can make an enormous difference. They can help a naturally impulsive child learn patience and a short-tempered person develop better emotional control.

But we should also accept that not every child responds to the same upbringing in the same manner.

There may be biological vulnerabilities that require additional understanding, patience and sometimes professional intervention.

This also has implications for adoptive families. Parents who lovingly bring up a child unrelated to them biologically should not be expected to control every aspect of his inherited temperament. Their contribution is measured by the care, opportunities and values they provide, not by whether the child turns out to be a perfect reflection of their own personalities.

However, there is another side to this argument.

If we begin attributing every undesirable action to DNA, will we eventually make our genes responsible for all our mistakes? A person with an inherited tendency towards anger cannot claim a licence to lose his temper whenever he wishes. A family history of addiction does not remove the responsibility to exercise caution and seek help.

A predisposition is not a compulsion. An inclination is not a destiny.

That is where science must meet common sense, and compassion must coexist with accountability.

Perhaps the most interesting lesson from Jeffrey Landrigan’s story is that human beings are much more complicated than the labels we give them. We are neither entirely products of our parents nor prisoners of our biological inheritance.

As I reflect on this story, I am reminded of how casually we often pass judgement on children by comparing them with their parents or siblings. We praise parents when their children excel and blame them when they go astray. But perhaps we need to understand the individual before judging the family.

A child’s personality is shaped by several forces working together. Some are visible, such as education, friendship and family surroundings. Others remain hidden in the biological code we receive at birth.

We may inherit our father’s appearance, our mother’s smile, a grandparent’s physical features or even certain temperamental tendencies. But thankfully, human life is not a computer programme in which every instruction must be followed without question.

DNA may provide the blueprint, upbringing may shape the building, but it is our choices that determine how we live in it.

After all, we cannot choose the genes with which we arrive in this world. But we can certainly make an effort not to pass on every weakness we inherit.

(The Author is Columnist | Former Banker | Social Commentator. He can be reached at anil.kumar.sharma9419@gmail.com)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *